Who Really Needs 15-Minute Grocery Delivery?
A new service that promises 15-minute grocery delivery at no additional cost “is the logical endpoint of a delivery-speed arms race that began 15 years ago when Amazon Prime guaranteed two-day delivery for millions of items,” writes Aaron Gordon. Founder Ralf Wenzel “says Jokr offers a more sustainable approach to food waste than the current grocery industry’s status quo, and that certain ideas about how to improve the efficiency of grocery delivery will allow the company to thrive.”
Aside from concerns about exploitative labor practices, experts question the benefits to consumers of such rapid-delivery services. “These companies operate only in dense urban neighborhoods where a grocery store is rarely more than a 10-minute walk away.” For Gordon, promises of near-instant gratification speak to the “dreams of a certain kind of urban dweller” who sees “every spontaneous public interaction is an inefficiency to be solved.”
Gordon points to dockless bike share that failed to make a profit and left cities littered with defunct bikes, food delivery services that “have thrown the restaurant industry into peril,” and ride-hailing services that have increased congestion and carbon emissions as other industries that “popped out of nowhere” thanks to venture capital funds and created economic and societal problems. Already, one of these companies, Gorillas, is struggling to reconcile the ultra-fast delivery dream with decent working conditions. The startup is facing worker unrest in Europe as delivery workers organize thanks to grueling delivery schedules and safety concerns.
Urban planning professor David King argues that “this idea of everything being delivered makes the city much more transitory, because we’re not experiencing the city, we’re not getting out.” To King, “these 15-minute services are missing something important about what cities are and why people like living in them.” The goal of city life for most people, he argues, is not “optimizing and efficiency.” Moving about the city is an essential part of living in one. As King puts it, “interesting things happen when you leave the house.”